Sunday, August 8, 2010

Drug use and regression

Regression historically has been seen as a defence mechanism. It involves the person reverting to an earlier state or mode of functioning. This is done because in the here and now the person is experiencing anxiety for some reason. In order to deal with that anxiety the person ‘escapes’ by regressing and becoming child like.


For instance if the person is involved in some kind of conflict, the person is being approached sexually, or the person is required to look after a child or become responsible for some reason. If these situations result in the person feeling anxious they can deal with their anxiety by ‘running away’ and becoming child like. Once done they don’t have to deal with the here and now situation and the anxiety is avoided.


Usually the stage to which the person regresses is determined by a fixation point. As we grow through our developmental stages we usually have trouble at some of them and thus don’t completely resolve them. These are then seen as fixation points so when the person regresses they will regress to the stage at which they are fixated. That maybe 3 years old for some or 8 years old for another.
Fire monkey

Every person is capable of regression, but some are more liable than others. There are many ways to regress. Those with significant fixations can regress spontaneously as in the situations described above. The more pressure and stress applied to a person the more likely they are to regress.


As I have written before

The mechanism of regression is supported by research in neuro-psychology as cited by Johnston (2009). When people are placed under stress they are less able to access the pre-frontal cortex of the brain which is associated with the more developed functions like problem solving, decision making and stress management (Adult ego state). Instead people tend to access the more primitive part of the brain in the amygdala (Child ego state).


In psychotherapy sometimes regressive techniques such as two chair are used. Indeed the therapeutic relationship in itself will pressure the client to regress and become more child like in the relationship with the therapist.


However one of the more efficient ways to regress is to consume alcohol and drugs. When done this situation evolves.
Parent, adult exclusion

Firstly the alcohol will diminish the Parent ego state and the person becomes disinhibited. The Parent ego state makes us behave in socially appropriate ways and thus people can become aggressive when drinking because their prohibitions against physically hitting out are diminished.

This is also the reason why some men like their female ‘dates’ to drink alcohol because they know it will lower the woman’s own internal prohibitions about sexual behaviour.

Tequila woman

With more consumption of the drug the Adult ego state is then decathected such that one is only left with the Child ego state and the regression is complete. Thus we have the link between drug use and the mechanism of regression. It seems reasonable to conclude that some drug users may have this motivation in their substance use. They are unconsciously motivated to regress.

If this is the case then there are treatment implications. As mentioned before the person will regress to that stage of development where they are fixated. Their normal psychological development for some reason got stuck at a particular stage and thus the Free Child seeks to return to that stage in the hope that somehow it will be resolved this time around.

The chronic alcohol user is often fixated at the oral stage of development which would require some kind of therapeutic resolution of the fixation there. That is to work through the developmental issues relevant to that stage with the therapist. If the person is using drugs for the need to regress then one would not expect the usual behavioural techniques to be all that effective.

Boxing woman

The thing about regression is that it is a running away or an escape from the here and now. Like the scared young child who simply closes her eyes and puts her hands over their ears as a way to deal with stress. In this sense regression as a defence mechanism is a very child like solution. Compared with intellectualisation which is sort of a more grown up reaction or other defence mechanisms where the Adult and Parent ego states do not disappear.

Of course a person who is regressed will attract others who will take on the parental role in a relationship with them. Thus we end up with people who are called enablers, co dependants and so forth. Of course they will say they want to husband to stop drinking, being child like and irresponsible but the other side of the wife does not.

With regression and drug counselling

Adult and Parent ego state development
Working through the fixation in the therapeutic relationship with the therapist
Altering relationships which encourage the regressive behaviour

Graffiti

Friday, July 30, 2010

Carl Rogers and health


Harriet states: I also thought of Carl Rogers when I read this. What did he say? Something like every person's goal should be to be the person who they truly are.



Carl said a lot of things Harriet. In his original writing there is a lot on transference that includes taped dialogue from sessions he did with clients. They are very interesting to read as one gets a bit of insight into how he worked as a therapist. However most of this is forgotten and he is most widely known for his clarification of the three essential features of the therapist in relationship with the client.


Genuiness - Therapist is aware of his own feelings, thoughts and attitudes and these are not concealed from the client.


Empathy - Understanding the client’s experience from the client’s point of view.


Unconditional positive regard - Conveying to the client that they are worthwhile humans no matter what they do.



Home wrecker


This has had a profound effect on the practice of psychotherapy which is why he is regarded as one of the greats of the field. As usual it is the simplicity that makes for it being more profound.


It seems reasonable to conclude that he was not the first to think this up. People would have known long before Rogers time that being genuine and empathetic was good for a relationship especially a helping relationship and I am sure teachers long before Rogers would have told their students such a thing. However he articulated it well and was in the right place at the right time and thus he became known as he is.


However this does raise an interesting and debated point of view. His approach and philosophy rests on the assumption that, “Love will cure it”. That is if you place a person into an environment or relationship that is genuine, empathetic and has unconditional positive regard they will naturally get better.


If you place a person in a nurturing and positive environment then their natural urge to grow and develop will be activated and the person will grow and develop towards psychological health. In transactional analysis terms it would be said that the Free Child aspect of the personality is energised or cathected and this is where the desire to grow towards health results from.




There is another school of thought that says, “Love alone is not enough for cure”. Without a doubt a loving, positive environment is good for one’s psychological health, but there is also an Adapted Child part of the personality that propels the person to ill health (or to their life script).


This side of the debate say that pure positivity is not enough to counter the drive to psychological ill health. At some point in the treatment you have to deal with this and that means doing something with the client that is experienced as painful in some way. That may be a confrontation of some kind that the client does not want to hear, getting the client to face their mother or father who abused them and so forth.


Some form of painful treatment is applied and this raises much heated debate. There are a group who say a client should never be subjected to painful treatment techniques with a common example being ECT or some form of aversion therapy like happened in the movie Clockwork Orange. You could argue that Carl Rogers would have been of the view that you do not apply painful treatments.



Carl Rogers workshop (1965)

My father back row third from right

Carl Rogers front and centre.


Of course there are much less dramatic painful techniques than ECT or aversion therapy and I certainly use some of them myself. For instance some two chair techniques could be placed in this category and this fits with my personal philosophy. Unconditional positive regard, empathy and genuiness as most useful in allowing the client to grow towards health but they are not enough in most instances. The AC is an active part of the personality that ‘love’ alone cannot over ride. It needs at some point to be dealt with directly and that usually involves some kind of angst for the client. Keep it to a minimum for sure but it is needed at times.


Graffiti

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

The 'x' factor in therapy


I was reading a book on counselling the other day and it discussed the therapeutic alliance. These two guys had done a meta analysis of the literature on what are ‘important therapist attributes’ for the development of a strong therapeutic alliance. They came up with:


Therapist attributes - flexible, honest, respectful, trustworthy, warm, confident, interested and open.


This seems like a reasonable list and includes some of the things one would expect to find. But this is indeed an elusive and indefinable topic. The quality that allows a good therapeutic alliance to develop between client and therapist. I have discussed this before and talked about the ‘x’ factor.



This is usually mentioned in relation to singers and musicians. There is a quality that the very good ones have that the not so good ones do not have. What that is however is largely indefinable, but you know when it is there and when it is not. A bit of an odd situation really - you know when it is there but you can’t define it (easily).


The same applies for the the therapeutic relationship. Some therapists have a ‘presence’ where they can have that special connection with clients, but what that is, is hard to define.


The list above is good and accurate but it’s one dimensional. It is a list of things and this will not define the ‘x’ factor. One cannot produce a list of things to do that. Instead one has to talk in more general terms that are less concrete because the ‘x’ factor itself in not concrete.


Theoretically it is quite easy to explain, it can be called the Free Child. This is best explained by looking at the training of therapists.



When therapists begin their trade they learn lots of things like how to do therapy and how to be a therapist. They learn the basic techniques and the basic process to follow. As they master these they become a therapist which undoubtedly is a positive thing. However it is an adaption and thus forms part of the Adapted Child ego state. They learn to be a certain way and a kind of professional role or way to be. They adapt to what authority is teaching them. The down side of this is they loose a sense of who they are and how to be themselves in the therapy setting. They are moving away from their Free Child part of the personality and becoming something else - an adaption.


This is not conducive to forming a connection with the client. The client will feel a sense of connection when the therapist simply be’s who they are. When they be them self which theoretically is the Free Child.


When client’s see the highly trained therapist they get good therapy that is of much assistance but that extra bit is not there. They do not get to meet the therapist as a person.



Some therapists never move beyond this because either they don’t particularly want to or they are not prepared to take the personal risk in doing so. To put the Free Child out in any relationship is a risk including the therapeutic relationship.


To move beyond ‘just’ being a therapist the person has to kind of unlearn what they have just spent the last few ( or many) years learning. They have to unlearn being a therapist and learn again how to be them self as a person in the therapy setting. If they achieve this then the Free Child again becomes accessible to the client and thus a special sense of connection can again occur. In my view this is part of the ‘x’ factor in the therapy setting.


The therapist moves away from being a therapist and becomes a person who happens to do therapy in the relationship with the client. The person comes first and the therapist part comes second. They have already acquired the therapy skills and now they relate to the client and happen to use those skills when necessary.


If the therapist allows self simply to be who they are in the therapy relationship then in my view the client experiences an extra dimension to the therapeutic relationship.

Just being who we are is surprisingly difficult. Most in childhood loose that ability.



Allowing self to just be who you are sounds simple, but is not easy. Indeed I would say that most people loose this after childhood and never achieve it again in adulthood, let alone those who have it trained out of them as happens in the training of therapists.


Graffiti

Monday, July 26, 2010

Cannabis and self medication.


Four types of drug use are commonly cited.


Experimental use

Recreational use

Symptomatic use

Dependent use


Symptomatic use is when the person uses the licit or illicit drug so as to solve a problem or treat a painful symptom. They discover that by using a certain drug they feel better because it treats a symptom. For instance heroin is an opiate. It is a pain killer. What better way to deal with your pain than to ‘kill’ it.




A person may have grown up in an abusive home and as a consequence they suffer pervasive depression and anxiety through their life. One day they try heroin and discover that that it makes them feel better because it gets rid of their depression and anxiety. So they try it again and obtain the same result. Thus they become a regular user of heroin because it alleviates their pain. This is sometimes called self medication. That is the person uses the drug to self medicate so as to ‘treat’ the symptom.


There is one type of self medicating that I have noticed over the years. These people use marijuana to self medicate. I would not say that it is a large group but you do come across them from time to time. This has recently been highlighted for me because I am working with a man where this type of drug use is quite obvious.


Marijuana for some people is effective in dealing with adulthood ADD or ADHD. I can’t say if it is for children as most people don’t start using cannabis until well into their teens. These people report that when they stop using they start to display the classic symptoms of ADD. The lack of focus, disorganisation, hyperactivity, insomnia and so forth. When they use marijuana the symptoms can subside significantly.



As a result of this they develop a particular pattern of use. It is different from the recreational user where the goal is to get stoned and experience the euphoria of the marijuana. This persons use is very intermittent. The cannabis user to self medicate for ADD uses much more consistently throughout the day and day after day.


The first use often occurs early in the day and then there is semi regular use throughout the day. This person does not get really stoned because they are continually half stoned all the time. Being continually stoned becomes their normality and they can function better due to the reduction of ADD symptoms. This is quite a different pattern of use compared to the recreational cannabis user.


Now one would usually say that the solution is obvious. This person needs to go to a psychiatrist, have a correct diagnosis of ADD made and then prescribed the appropriate ADD medication. Unfortunately it is not that simple.


Some have even done this but found that medications like dexamphetamines are not as effective. From what I have heard reported, marijuana can be a very effective treatment for the ADD symptoms. Just because its illegal is not a reason to stop in many a users mind.




Secondly, this type of marijuana user must have good connections in the drug scene. They have established a consistent supply over a long period of time. Now one thing you do not want to do when working with a drug user is introduce them to yet another drug, whether it is legal or not. Especially a drug like dexamphetamine which is very saleable in the drug subculture and can be used to make some good money.


The solution to this type of cannabis user is a difficult one indeed. I have yet to find a good one really. Maybe some other management skills for their ADD symptoms could help and just learning to live with it.


Graffiti

Saturday, July 24, 2010

Client's asking difficult questions


I bought a book the other day on addictions counselling and it is quite good. Most Australian produced books on this topic stick with CBT and that’s it. This book does the CBT but also looks at the therapeutic alliance as they call it. They deal with the process between the client and therapist as well which is good to see.


In it they make a interesting comment which one finds from time to time. In discussing the client therapist relationship they look at what does a therapist say if a client asks the therapist if he/she is sexually attracted to them. They say the therapist should respond by neither confirming or disconfirming any sexual attraction to the client. Instead the therapist should ask why such a question is important to the client and explore the thoughts and feelings the client has about wanting to know and so forth.



They state that for the emotionally robust client this will permit a much deeper exploration of their reactions, hopes, fears and wants than if the therapist revealed their exact feelings. For the emotionally fragile client they say it would be too anxiety provoking for the therapist to answer directly.


This is a view held by some approaches that one sees from time to time. The problem is I don’t believe their reasoning behind not answering the question. It has too much of a flavour of a therapist ducking for cover by hiding in their theory. It is a very convenient response for the therapist that keeps them emotionally safe and allows them to slip side ways out of a difficult series of transactions.


Whilst one gets this question from time to time the more common one is when the client asks the therapist if he/she is angry at them. The approach cited above would do the same in this instance. They would not answer the question and seek to know why such a question is important for the client, explore feelings and so forth.




Regardless of your theory or beliefs about the therapeutic relationship the bottom line is one person has asked another person a direct question and the other person refuses to answer it. Most often the client will ask because they think they are picking up an ulterior transaction from the therapist. If this is the case then client is doing good open direct communication. If you sense something in a relationship then asking about it in an open and direct way is good communication.


So the client does this and then the therapist blocks it by not answering in a direct and open way. At the very least the therapist is modelling bad communication styles and saying, “Do as I say, not as I do”.


In addition to this I think the client’s question of are you attracted (or angry) to me, carries another question imbedded in it. The client is asking the therapist to be a human with the client in that instance. The client is asking for a simple piece of human to human communication. In response the therapist refuses and answers as a therapist. In my view this is disrespectful to the client.


The therapist not answering the question


Regardless of not respecting the client as a human in my view not answering the question is bad from a therapeutic point of view anyway. If you ask someone a question and they respond by giving you lots of words that does not answer the question what then happens in side you? It immediately builds up FC curiosity. If you ask a question and don’t get an answer the FC stills wants its question answered and now it also wants to know why you didn’t answer the question in the first place. That seems like a natural reaction if you don’t get a question answered.


After all the analysis and exploration the client is still going to wonder what the therapist feels about them. But now they know not to ask the question as they wont get an answer.


It makes it an issue when it doesn’t have to be. If you answer the question directly it defuses it and then the relationship can move forward. If you don’t answer the question it makes it an issue in the relationship that just complicates matters. If answered directly in a careful way no client is going to be damaged by it. Their intuitive Little Professor ego state knows the answer anyway.



Body language. Client’s watch the body language of the therapist very closely.



Theory smeary! Throw away all your theory and therapeutic explanations and asks self:


What does my FC feel towards this client at this time?

What’s in it for my FC not to answer the question?


This is what the client will be asking self after you refuse to answer the question. - What does the therapist’s FC feel about me and what’s in it for their FC to not answer my question?


Graffiti

Sunday, July 18, 2010

The process of projection in transference


I will answer your question with this post Roses.


The script imago diagram is one way of showing how transference occurs in relationships.




This diagram comes from here.


As the child grows it forms relationship prototypes or relationship templates. These are shows as the slots in the script imago diagram which are categorised into three types. As the child grows it establishes its relationship with mother and father. This will include all the good stuff and all the not so good stuff including the unmet needs of the child. These are usually formed in the first decade of life and become the templates for later relationships.


As the child grows into adulthood it will begin to establish relationships similar to those templates established in childhood. The person will unconsciously select people like mother and also project onto the person mother like qualities. Thus the same types of relationships will occur over and over in the persons life. The psychological process of projection is an integral part of this process.


There are three types of transference described here. Those people whom we see as more psychologically potent than we are the parental figures or transference figures in our life. We will tend to project these templates onto people in our current life who are also seen as more psychologically potent than we are. Therapy is a perfect setting for a client to see the therapist as a more psychologically potent figure (parent figure) and hence the parent figure slots are projected onto the therapist.



If the son went into therapy over time he would begin to see the therapist in the same light as his father’s haranguing. This is done by him using the psychological process of projection.



People can also develop counter transference or dependent figure templates for relationships. Often this is done by older siblings on younger siblings. This happens particularly if the parents use the older sibling as a live in baby sitter and structure the relationship so the older one takes on a parental role with the younger one. Thus the older sibling develops a strong prototype for such relationships. These people in adulthood can become therapists who spend their working life looking after others who are in the child like position in the relationship.


Thus we have counter transference and the therapist can project their archaic image onto the client and this is where problems may develop in the therapy. The younger child can also use the older sibling as another parent figure slot. Some times youngest children have very few (and even sometimes nil) dependent figure slots.


In adulthood they are unlikely to seek an occupation where they are the looking after parental one like a therapist or nurse. It just wont feel right and they will not be comfortable in that role. They will tend to be more child like and self centered and end up in relationships that have that quality.



A child like profession in adulthood


Finally we have sibling transference. If the siblings or peers are allowed to interact as equals they can develop equal figure or sibling transference slots in their script imago. These are the templates they use in adulthood for equal power relationships. If a child was isolated for some reason then it may develop few and sometimes no slots for this type of transference. Children who are home schooled can have this difficulty or when parents for some reason do not allow the child to interact a lot with its peers. Only children can also do this.


In each case the process of projection is used by the person who projects the template onto the other. It can do this with the good qualities of the relationship and the not so good qualities. If the person had good quality and co-operative relationships with its siblings then these will be projected onto equal figures in adulthood. If it was encouraged to be very competitive with its peers by the parents then in adulthood this will tend to show out in the equal relationships. The person will project this onto the other.



How the soldiers relate to each other will depend on the projection of the early relationships they had with their siblings


As we can see this is different from the defence mechanism of projection. In that instance the process of projection is used to hide from some part of our personality that we do not like. In transference the process of projection is used such that earlier templates for relationships can be employed in our current day life.


Graffiti

Saturday, July 17, 2010

Transference and projection



Roses asks, “Is projection a lot different to transference then?”



Many do say that transference involves a good deal of projection but that is not actually accurate in the technical theoretical sense.


Projection was originally hypothesised as a defence mechanism. Its goal is to allow the person to maintain a positive self image. It allows the person to view self in a positive light which we all want to do.


We all have Child ego state urges that our Parent ego state does not think is right, good or proper. If we consciously acknowledge these in our Adult ego state then we feel bad about ourselves. They usually involve things like sexual thoughts, greed, envy, revenge and even feelings which some see as bad such as anger.




A good example of this is the passive aggressive personality. A woman has angry and aggressive feelings in herself which her Parent ego state thinks is bad. To maintain a positive view of self she must push these feelings into her unconscious so she is not aware of them. She can use projection to do this and will start to see those around her as being angry and aggressive as the passive aggressive personality tends to do. They tend to feel poorly and unfairly treated by the angry others around her and tends to view self as righteous and decent.


Of course her unconscious anger does not go away so she will also express it in a passive way such as with sarcasm, bitchiness, slight ridicule and so forth. With the proficient passive aggressive person, after talking with them for a time you start to feel bad (and maybe even angry) and you kind of don’t know why. They are so good at hiding the expression of their anger you don’t even know it is happening. That is one of the tell tale signs of the passive aggressive personality you come away from then feeling bad about something and you can’t really figure out why.




However getting back to the point. The passive aggressive personality often uses the projection of their anger out onto others so as to defend their own self perception.


Transference involves “placing mother or father’s face onto the therapist or another person”. That does sound very projection like and often the person is quite unaware they are doing it which is also a feature of the defence mechanism of projection.


However in transference the wife’s projection of father’s face onto her husband is not to defend ones self perception. She is not doing it to keep some unwanted urge or feeling in her unconscious. Hence it is not a defence mechanism in the technical sense of the word. Thus one could argue that it is not projection which is a defence mechanism which is designed to keep something out of the conscious.



So what does one conclude? It seems to me that humans are capable of projecting out internal feelings, thoughts, urges and relationship prototypes and so forth onto others in the world. We are all capable of the psychological process of projection. However there are a variety of reasons why a person would employ the process of projection of which all humans are capable. Thus we have two aspects of projection.


1. The psychological projection process.


2. The psychological motive behind the projection.


If the motive is to keep some undesirable feeling in the unconscious then we have the defence mechanism of projection.


If the motive is to place a relationship template onto another person then we have transference projection.


In answer to your question Roses. In transference people will use the psychological projection process but for different motives than it is used in the defence mechanism of projection.


Graffiti