What do you mean about the comment for the cat?
In this situation I would do the script analysis through a dialogue with Kahless. I don’t know you well enough to use a purely interpretative approach. If I do know the person well then I am prepared to make more interpretative statements. I know I have done a family photographs script analysis with you in the past so I do know a bit about your life script but I by no means know you well. Thus I will make statements or ask questions and if you have a response (its OK if you don’t) then from that we will come up with the early decisions you made and thus identify your life script. So it is a collaborative process rather than a purely interpretative one by me.
The whole incident is about oral issues. The force feeding of a child. The fact that it happened 4 times a year for a number of years gives it much more psychological weight and could be quite a significant event event in terms of the development of your life script.
I must say I did delight in your sister’s response to such ‘feeding’. Such defiance! She didn’t reject such feeding by vomiting the purple medicine in the toilet bowl or even on the floor but she managed to get the kitchen curtains.
As it suggests oral issues that means we are talking about an early stage of development, indeed the earliest as the oral stage is the first stage. This suggests the potential for a significant level of maladjustment. Potentially a third degree impasse and preverbal issues.
This can be viewed in terms of Erik Erikson’s theory of the 8 stages of psychosocial child development. The first stage being the stage of trust vs mistrust thus there is the potential for our first early decision - “Don’t trust”. This can manifest as being too under trusting or too over trusting or trusting untrustworthy people. What ever it might, there is the potential for problems around trust in human communication.
The only facial features shown on any of the people is a mouth on mother and it looks like there is a mouth on the sister? Which might indicate further evidence for the significance of oral issues. If these exist then one is looking for problems around feeding, the mouth, eating and so forth. Eating disorders, problems with weight, problem with defiance and authority. As the scene is food related it could also result in digestion problems as you mention the feeling you had when confronted with this scene was “a horrible stirring in the pit of my stomach”.
The other potential difficulty one looks for with oral issues is addictions particularly where the mouth is involved. That is alcohol or an addiction to cigarettes. If the cigarette addiction is based on maladjustment at the oral stage then the treatment would be the amelioration of such issues. That may require preverbal treatment methods such as holding.
Graffiti
-----------------------
Response
I put the cat in the picture a little bit tongue in cheek, although the need to take this medicine was blamed by my parents on the cat. I tend to steer clear of cats as an adult if I can and avoid touching and stroking them.
At the time I was horrified by my sisters behaviour but as an adult I, too delight in her defiance with a wry smile. I have learnt as an adult that all her 'God Squad' religious behaviour as a teenager (she hung out with such types) was really a front to get out of the house. So she had a cover story (as did my brother) to stay out late. I wasn't that smart.
"Don't trust" isn't something I must say I am actively aware of, though I am an extremely private person. Whilst I have absolutely no problem sharing whatever here and I am not bothered in the slightest if anyone asks me anything here. But then again my on-line life here is compartmentalised and no-one in my RL everyday world know's I am Kahless. I have a number of on-line identities too. I could vanish whenever I wanted. People at work don't know much about my life. So I guess I am wary of trust. I am definitely not over trusting and I assess people before I trust them, so generally don't trust untrustworthy persons. I also 99% of the time don't reveal anything to anyone that I would be concerned about other people knowing.
Yes there is a mouth on my sister. Funny really, I hadn't noticed lack of facial features until you pointed it out. What I think it is worth saying is that - in general terms - my brother and I tend to be more like our father and my sister tends to be more like my mum.
My brother is obese as an adult.
My father tended to be on the chubbier side and my mother always nagged him about his weight.
I remember my mum always saying my sister was 'picky' with her food.
I am within my normal weight range but at the moment probably at the high end, though I tend to vary within a stone weight range.
I do actually have a motto around food. "I eat what I want, when I want." I guess I didn't have that control as a kid so I certainly am going to have it as an adult. There are certain foods - like ham sandwich, bowls of cereal and pizza (my favourites) which I like to prepare myself. Mrs K will offer to do it, but I like to do it myself. I will only eat certain foods. I hate it if people touch my food. I eat fast. I prefer to eat alone and don't like to talk while I eat. And I eat what I want, when I want!
I have a digestive disease - Crohn's Disease - which was first diagnosed when I was 16. I was pretty ill until around 21 when I had 4 foot of large intestine removed. The disease isnt active now but I do have issues due to a shortened bowel - ie I live with diarrhoea.
My father had in later life (after my op) a part of bowel removed due to a blockage. His twin brother has had bowel cancer.
I have no problem with authority - I was always a good child and obeyed. I do so generally as an adult too.
I nearly drew the scene when I opened the door to the local newsagent holding both my brother and sister by the scruff of the neck and wanting to speak to my parents - he had caught them stealing sweets. My brother also had another such incident as a teenager when the school caught him stealing money from the tuck shop.
No-one in my family have criminal convictions so I guess ultimately tow the line. BTW my brother is an accountant now!
I am a smoker - I had my first cigarette at 18.
Neither my brother nor sister have ever smoked.
My parents gave up smoking when I was about 5.
I would not feel comfortable with a treatment method of "holding" - I am not really a touchy feely person - except of course with my dogs where I shower affection and allow them to adore me! I also don't do intimacy very well.
--------------------------
My response:
It seems I have missed the original point of the exercise which was a thought about early decisions. So there that young girl is and all those things were going on in front of her.
What sense did she make of it all?
With all that, what conclusions did she come to?
How would she finish this sentence, “It just goes to show you that....”?
What did she decide about herself and others and life as a result of this repeated event?
If you can answer these questions then you have an early decision. It is the cognitive conclusions that the child comes to in reaction to such adverse circumstances.
In the HTP test one would notice that all the figures have no facial features except for the two with mouths and also there are no hands drawn. The brother does not even have arms. Such things are all about human contact and the exchange of strokes one could say.
This combined with the fact that the house is drawn basically like a box and has very little homeliness about it. These things could indicate something like human relationships that are emotionally bereft and possible stroke deprivation.
This would immediately highlight for me your comments about preverbal therapy such as holding and your aversion to it. If you should ever end up in therapy it might be something to look at. In addition a therapy style can also allow the client to develop the ability to self soothe. Those who cannot do such things when they get into emotional distress find it very hard to get out because they have difficulty soothing self and hence they tend to stay in the emotional turmoil for longer.
The early decision here would most likely be something like, “Don’t be close” or “Don’t feel”, “Don’t get your needs met” and so forth.
The other point from the HTP test is the centrality of the figures. You are font and center and the actual incident is off to the side. You have also circled your name unlike anyone else. I know from the family photograph script analysis we did that in the photos you were also often front and center. In the HTP test this would indicate psychological importance of the figures in your mind.
I know from what you have stated in the past one could at times also see for you a “Don’t be important” early decision. This is inconsistent with what I am saying now so you may be a contradiction in this way. The good child who does the right thing often is also not noticed much they tend to be a wall flower. From what I have seen of you, you are not that! You will be ‘front and center’ at times being quite noticeable. So any early decisions about lack of importance or worth are certainly not 100%.
Graffiti
Wow! This is interesting and fun. My answers / observations...
ReplyDeleteI put the cat in the picture a little bit tongue in cheek, although the need to take this medicine was blamed by my parents on the cat. I tend to steer clear of cats as an adult if I can and avoid touching and stroking them.
At the time I was horrified by my sisters behaviour but as an adult I, too delight in her defiance with a wry smile. I have learnt as an adult that all her 'God Squad' religious behaviour as a teenager (she hung out with such types) was really a front to get out of the house. So she had a cover story (as did my brother) to stay out late. I wasn't that smart.
"Don't trust" isn't something I must say I am actively aware of, though I am an extremely private person. Whilst I have absolutely no problem sharing whatever here and I am not bothered in the slightest if anyone asks me anything here. But then again my on-line life here is compartmentalised and no-one in my RL everyday world know's I am Kahless. I have a number of on-line identities too. I could vanish whenever I wanted. People at work don't know much about my life. So I guess I am wary of trust. I am definitely not over trusting and I assess people before I trust them, so generally don't trust untrustworthy persons. I also 99% of the time don't reveal anything to anyone that I would be concerned about other people knowing.
Yes there is a mouth on my sister. Funny really, I hadn't noticed lack of facial features until you pointed it out. What I think it is worth saying is that - in general terms - my brother and I tend to be more like our father and my sister tends to be more like my mum.
My brother is obese as an adult.
My father tended to be on the chubbier side and my mother always nagged him about his weight.
I remember my mum always saying my sister was 'picky' with her food.
I am within my normal weight range but at the moment probably at the high end, though I tend to vary within a stone weight range.
I do actually have a motto around food. "I eat what I want, when I want." I guess I didn't have that control as a kid so I certainly am going to have it as an adult. There are certain foods - like ham sandwich, bowls of cereal and pizza (my favourites) which I like to prepare myself. Mrs K will offer to do it, but I like to do it myself. I will only eat certain foods. I hate it if people touch my food. I eat fast. I prefer to eat alone and don't like to talk while I eat. And I eat what I want, when I want!
I have a digestive disease - Crohn's Disease - which was first diagnosed when I was 16. I was pretty ill until around 21 when I had 4 foot of large intestine removed. The disease isnt active now but I do have issues due to a shortened bowel - ie I live with diarrhoea.
My father had in later life (after my op) a part of bowel removed due to a blockage. His twin brother has had bowel cancer.
I have no problem with authority - I was always a good child and obeyed. I do so generally as an adult too.
I nearly drew the scene when I opened the door to the local newsagent holding both my brother and sister by the scruff of the neck and wanting to speak to my parents - he had caught them stealing sweets. My brother also had another such incident as a teenager when the school caught him stealing money from the tuck shop.
No-one in my family have criminal convictions so I guess ultimately tow the line. BTW my brother is an accountant now!
I am a smoker - I had my first cigarette at 18.
Neither my brother nor sister have ever smoked.
My parents gave up smoking when I was about 5.
I would not feel comfortable with a treatment method of "holding" - I am not really a touchy feely person - except of course with my dogs where I shower affection and allow them to adore me! I also don't do intimacy very well.
It really is interesting isn't it Kahless. I'm constantly amazed how full on life (while growing up) really is and the impact it has on us, not only as adults but all the way through to our elderlyness.
ReplyDeleteI know you don't understand it when i say it Tony, but i still want to be just like you some day. And i don't even care if i have to be older to be it. I'm older today than i was yesterday and can hardly tell - 'hardly' mind.
Ok, another interesting thing came up - how do you treat pre-verbal trauma? I think most of the stuff I actually remember, I dealt with well both at the time and later in life when reflecting back, but a lot of my general unsettled-ness comes from really early abuse...what can be done about that?
ReplyDeleteThank you Roses, you can be lovely sometimes.
ReplyDeleteI too am older today than I was yesterday
Tony
Hello Sara,
ReplyDeleteI was going to respond to your comment but as I started writing I realized that I knew all this stuff that I did not know I knew. About working with clients with pre verbal issues. Just things I have done over the years and seen other therapists do with clients. So it has now become a post in the making. Watch this space!
Graffiti
I'm glad your sister got the curtains, Kahless, and I hope it left a stain.
ReplyDeleteI never fully realised until I read Tony's analysis, how much we have in common. As you know, I have food and medicine issues, too. I was also force fed, but with food instead of medicine. By the time I was 19 I was six feet tall and weighed 115 pounds and was weak and sickly because of it. I understand about eating or not eating certain things. To this day I think I would vomit if I tried to eat brussel sprouts or overcooked meat.
Tony, it was interesting to me that you interpreted the boxiness and lack of detail in the house as being bereft. This gives me some insight into my own drawing which is full of boxes and stick figures and lacks even the most basic detail and order. I had previously thought it to be just 'poor drawing skills', now I wonder.
Hello Lynn,
ReplyDeleteWhen a person is wanting to do drawing analysis and the client says "I can't draw" then that is good news. The person who has been taught how to draw may give a drawing that is of little psychological worth because their drawing is based on good drawing technique and not from the heart (or life script) which is what is needed in drawing analysis.
Tony
Hi Lynn,
ReplyDeleteWhy don't you put your drawing up on your blog and I will make some comments about it
Tony
Cool Graffiti.
ReplyDeleteI have loads comments to make but they will have to wait cos I am in he middle of my working day. So tonight I will be back.
Hi Roses,
ReplyDeleteYes this is dead interesting. And I love reading what everyone is saying.
Hi EH,
ReplyDeletemy mother had to bleach the white net curtains to get the purple stain out, hehehee!
I hope you share your drawing. In fact I will go check out your blog when I have finished my comments here.
{{{{{Lynn}}}}}}
One of the many good things about Tony's blog is that I made a friend of you.
What sense did she make of it all?
ReplyDeleteWith all that, what conclusions did she come to?
How would she finish this sentence, “It just goes to show you that....”?
I find these questions too hard to answer. I find it hard to place myself back into that little girls mind. All I know is that sinking feeling in the stomach. The "fuck" moment. Yet I didn't know swear words at that age! It did all seem a contradiction. Going from the happy smell of freshly cut grass on the rounders field to the horror of this scene at home.
I actually drew the HTP some time ago here... I guess the person in this instance had facial features, though I remember trying to draw at my bestest, rather than think of a situation which I have here. But I guess there is contradiction.
My last T but one went down the dont feel route. I never once cried in his presence and I kind of felt a bit of a pressure cos he encouraged me to feel sadness. I kind of think he wanted me to cry but nope, never came!
It is funny, that I noticed myself circling my name immediately after I did it. I was tempted to then go back and even it up by circling everybody else's but then I felt that may have been cheating. I am not sure that dont be important was an early decision. What really grates on me is when I think people are ignoring me / I am not being listened too. That presses my buttons I realised.
I have enjoyed doing all of this; its been really interesting. Thank-you.